When Old Deceptions Wear New Costumes
A few years ago, Shaun Tabatt walked into a session at the IANDS annual conference and was surprised by what he found. The topic of the session was not the tunnel, the light, or the life review. It was alien encounters. People who had reported near-death experiences were, in many cases, also reporting contact with what they called "star beings." Tabatt admitted he had spent more than five years researching NDEs and had no idea this overlap even existed.1 But there it was, on the conference program, sitting next to the more familiar NDE testimonies. He realized he could not write a serious book on the dark edges of the NDE movement without addressing it.
Neither can we. If you spend any time at all in the modern NDE world — at conferences, on YouTube channels, in best-selling books — you will eventually run into accounts that blend NDE phenomena with UFO contact, channeled wisdom from "the galactics," past lives on other planets, and "ancient alien" theories about the origins of religion. These claims often arrive dressed in scientific-sounding language. They feel modern, cosmic, and forward-looking. And they are presented as the next step beyond traditional Christianity.
This chapter asks a careful question. What should Christians make of NDE accounts that include "star beings" who teach a new spirituality? My argument is this: when these encounters are real, they are best explained as demonic deceptions wearing the costume of the space age. The biblical framework for evaluation does not come from UFO studies but from Scripture's own demonology. The technology is new. The pattern is ancient.
Before going further, we should be honest about how common these reports actually are. They are loud, but they are not the majority. J. Steve Miller, who has done careful statistical work on the largest online NDE database (NDERF), searched all the experiences on the site for the word "alien." Most uses of the word turned out to be descriptions of how strange the experience felt — "this was completely alien to me." Only a small number actually described seeing or learning about aliens. Miller estimates that roughly six out of every thousand NDEs on the NDERF site mention alien encounters in this stronger sense — less than one percent.2
That number matters in two directions. First, it means that NDEs do not really provide evidence for alien life. Reports of Buddha or Krishna are even rarer; we do not say NDEs prove those figures, and we should not say it of aliens either.3 Second, it means that when authors and conference speakers present alien material as if it were a normal feature of the afterlife, they are giving a misleading picture of the data. The mainstream of NDE testimony does not run through the galactic federation.
And yet the trickle is real, and it is growing. The overlap between the NDE community and the UFO/contactee community has become a steady stream. Some popular speakers move freely between the two worlds. Some books market themselves to both audiences. Tabatt observes — and I think he is right — that this is one of several "doors" through which unbiblical material is being smuggled into the NDE space.4 A small percentage of NDEs may speak of aliens, but a much larger percentage of NDE conferences now feature them. Christians who care about discernment cannot ignore this.
One last clarification before we go further. This chapter is not arguing about whether God could create physical life on other planets. He could, if He wished. The question here is narrower. When beings show up in someone's NDE and present themselves as cosmic teachers with a new spiritual message, what is going on? That is the question we have to answer.
When you read enough of this material, four patterns emerge again and again.
The experiencer encounters benevolent beings who deliver a message: humanity is on the verge of an evolutionary leap. A "galactic federation" or "council of light" is watching from the stars, waiting for us to mature. This particular experiencer has been chosen to share the message. The gospel of this pattern is that we are not falling short of God's holiness but climbing a cosmic ladder. We do not need a Savior. We need an upgrade.
This pattern stitches together reincarnation (which I addressed in Chapter 23) with extraterrestrial contact. The NDEr is told that before this earthly life, their soul lived on another world — perhaps Sirius, perhaps the Pleiades. Earth is just one stop on a long journey. This combination is especially potent because it weaves two unbiblical strands (reincarnation and ET contact) into a single story that feels coherent and even comforting to those who already believe in pre-existence.
The being met during the NDE is identified as one of the "ascended masters" — Jesus, perhaps, but also Buddha, Krishna, Saint Germain, and others. These masters are reframed as evolved cosmic intelligences who came to teach humanity. The "ascended masters" idea is not an ancient Christian doctrine. It comes from nineteenth-century Theosophy, and its adoption by NDE literature is a recent development. When this pattern shows up, you are reading Theosophy in NDE clothing.
Popularized by Erich von Däniken and amplified by television programs, the "ancient aliens" framework claims humanity was seeded, taught, or even genetically engineered by extraterrestrial visitors. What our ancestors called "God" was actually space travelers. What they called "angels" were astronauts. What we call "Scripture" is a memory of cosmic visitations, badly understood. Some NDE teachers absorb this framework and present it as the deeper meaning of their experiences.5 This is a direct attack on biblical revelation.
Each of these four patterns flatters the experiencer ("you are special, you have been chosen"), promises hidden knowledge ("the church does not know what we know"), and quietly displaces Christ ("Jesus is one teacher among many"). The Bible has a name for this kind of message, and it is not "good news from the cosmos."
So how do we test these accounts? Scripture gives us four converging lines of evaluation.
The biblical universe is not empty, but it is also not crowded with mysterious advanced races. Scripture describes God the Creator; humans, made in His image, dwelling on the earth He gave us; angels, who are spiritual beings appointed to minister; and fallen angels, who actively deceive. There is no biblical category for "physically embodied intelligent life from other planets coming to guide humanity into truth." If such life existed, it would be created by God and accountable to Him — not a substitute for Him. Scripture's silence on this category is not a gap waiting to be filled. It is significant.6
Whether or not physical aliens exist somewhere, the pattern of contactee and alien-NDE accounts lines up with what Scripture says about deceptive spirits in startling detail. Paul warns: "Even Satan disguises himself as an angel of light. So it is no surprise if his servants, also, disguise themselves as servants of righteousness" (2 Corinthians 11:14-15, ESV).7
Look at the contactee profile and compare it with that warning. The beings appear in light. They flatter the experiencer. They claim to be benevolent teachers of higher wisdom. They contradict or relativize biblical revelation. They offer alternative readings of Scripture (the "ancient aliens" frame). They direct the person toward channeling, mediumship, or other occult practices. They sometimes induce paralysis and fear. And without exception, the doctrines they leave behind are at odds with biblical Christianity. That is not a coincidence. That is a fingerprint.
What we now call "alien contact" sits inside a much older pattern. In medieval Europe, similar encounters were reported, but the beings were called fairies. In the nineteenth century, similar phenomena appeared in spiritualist seances, where the beings were called "the dear departed." In tribal cultures, similar contact was sought through shamanic ritual, where the beings were called spirit guides. The Christian UFO researcher John Keel observed long ago that the costumes change while the play stays the same.8 Christian researcher Gary Bates has documented the same continuity from a clearly biblical standpoint in his work Alien Intrusion: pre-technological people met "spirits"; post-technological people meet "aliens"; the abduction phenomena, the sexual elements, the doctrinal content, and the mockery of Christianity are remarkably similar across the eras.9
This is the most diagnostic test. In account after account, the "alien teachings" deny or relativize core Christian truth. Christ is not unique. The Bible is a distortion. Sin is an illusion. Humanity is its own savior. Salvation is by cosmic evolution. The church has been hiding the real story. Whatever else we might say, this is exactly the doctrinal pattern Paul warned about: "But even if we or an angel from heaven should preach to you a gospel contrary to the one we preached to you, let him be accursed" (Galatians 1:8, ESV). A different gospel is a different gospel, no matter who delivers it. Whether the messenger looks like a robed elder or a tall gray with almond eyes does not change the rule.
The test of any spiritual messenger is not their appearance, their technology, or their claim to authority. The test is what they teach. A "messenger from the stars" who relativizes Christ and contradicts Scripture is, by Paul's standard, anathema — even if their ship looked impressive.
Here is one of the most striking pieces of evidence in this whole conversation. There is a remarkably consistent pattern across alien abduction reports: when the experiencer calls on the name of Jesus, the encounter abruptly stops.
The Australian Christian researcher Gary Bates has gathered over four hundred such cases over twenty-five years of work in this field, where calling on Jesus halted the abduction in progress.10 Tabatt records similar testimonies, including a chilling first-person account from a young person who described being seized in their bed by gray figures, unable to move or even speak the word "Jesus" — until at last the name came out and the whole scene collapsed.11 No physical extraterrestrial species would care about a first-century Galilean carpenter. No drug-induced hallucination would have a theological allergy. But fallen angels would. And do.
This test is not a magic spell. It works because Jesus is Lord, and demons must obey Him. Tabatt is careful not to claim that Jesus' name halting the encounter, by itself, settles the question. But he is right that, alongside the doctrinal pattern, the historical continuity, and the abduction phenomena, it is one more line of evidence pointing toward the same conclusion: in many of these cases, what looks like alien contact is actually demonic activity.12
The book naming names is part of being useful, so let me briefly identify a few figures whose work appears in this stream and whom Christian readers should approach with discernment. None of this is gossip. It is fair description of public teaching.
Whitley Strieber. His 1987 book Communion became one of the foundational texts of the modern abduction literature. In later books and interviews, Strieber has woven in NDE-like elements: out-of-body travel, encounters with deceased relatives, transmissions of cosmic teaching from "the visitors." His theological conclusions are non-Christian and sometimes openly anti-Christian. The honest evaluation: a long-running encounter pattern with classic demonic markers, packaged in cutting-edge UFO language.
Dr. Steven Greer. Founder of the Disclosure Project and Sirius Disclosure, Greer is the most prominent contemporary advocate for what he calls peaceful ET contact. He teaches meditation techniques designed to invite contact, and his framework treats traditional religions — Christianity especially — as obstacles to cosmic awakening. Whatever one thinks of his political claims, the spiritual content of his program is openly incompatible with biblical Christianity.
Erich von Däniken and the "ancient aliens" tradition. Von Däniken's 1968 book Chariots of the Gods? kicked off the modern claim that biblical events are dim memories of ET contact. His arguments have been thoroughly critiqued by scholars and historians. But the framework has had cultural staying power. When it shows up in NDE teaching — "what we call God was really beings from space" — it is not biblical Christianity in any sense. It is a direct denial of Christianity.
NDE conference speakers who weave in alien material. Tabatt's IANDS observations point to a real and growing phenomenon. Some speakers move comfortably between NDE platforms and contactee circles. Christians who attend such conferences should be prepared to encounter material that goes well past traditional NDE phenomenology into full-blown contactee theology.
If a friend tells you they had an NDE that included alien beings, do not panic, and do not lecture. Listen. Ask gentle questions. What did the beings teach? What practices did they encourage? What has happened in your spiritual life since? The doctrinal content and the spiritual fruit will tell you more than the imagery ever could. People are more important than diagnoses.
Some readers will press the question: what if there really are physical extraterrestrials, and these contacts are with them? Three layered responses are worth thinking through.
Layer 1: The doctrinal test still applies. Even if a physical alien did exist and somehow contacted a human, Paul's words in Galatians 1:8 still hold. A different gospel from a different planet is still a different gospel. Scripture is the standard, not the species.
Layer 2: The phenomenology does not match physical contact. The specific features of contactee experiences — telepathic teaching, paralysis, abduction through walls, missing time, channeled messages, induced occult practices, anti-Christian doctrine — do not match what you would expect from physically embodied beings. They match what Scripture describes as the activity of fallen angels: spirit, not space, is the right category.
Layer 3: Some physical phenomena may have ordinary explanations, but the "teachings" do not. Even if some unidentified aerial phenomena turn out to be advanced military technology, atmospheric oddities, or other natural causes, that does not account for the spiritual component. The beings with messages — the part that actually matters for our discussion — remain best explained by Scripture's demonology, not by aerospace engineering.
A small but real subset of NDEs include alien content directly inside the experience. The discernment principles from Chapter 9 — the experience–interpretation distinction — apply here with full force.
It is possible that some of these NDEs included a real spiritual core (an out-of-body experience, an encounter with light) which the experiencer then interpreted through a UFO lens because that lens was already in their mind. The light that an experiencer met may have been God, an angel, or even Christ — but the experiencer, having spent years on UFO podcasts, may have read the encounter as "an interdimensional being." It is also possible that the beings encountered were genuinely deceptive spirits, taking on the costume that would best fool that particular experiencer.
In either case, the test is the same. What was taught? Does it agree with Scripture? What fruit has come out of it? An NDEr who came back from their experience telling everyone that Jesus is just one cosmic teacher and that the Bible is an outdated record of contact events has not, whatever else happened, been told the truth. The interpretation needs to be challenged, even if a real spiritual encounter sits underneath it.13
· · ·
The biblical picture of the universe is not narrow or quaint. It is vast and crowded with meaning. There is one God, eternal in three Persons, who created all things visible and invisible. There is a heavenly host of angels who serve at His command. There are fallen powers, real but defeated, who deceive the world for a time. There are humans, made a little lower than the angels but crowned with glory and honor (Psalm 8), invited into communion with God through Jesus Christ. The conscious dead who belong to Christ are with Him now in paradise.14 The dead who do not belong to Him are in Hades, awaiting judgment. And one day, all things will be made new.
That picture does not need to be supplemented with a galactic federation, ascended cosmic teachers, or genetic interventions from Sirius. It does not need to be revised by ancient astronaut theories or by channeled messages from the Pleiades. The biblical cosmos is enough — not because it is small, but because it is centered on the One who is large enough to fill it.
When NDE accounts feature "aliens" as spiritual teachers, we should recognize the pattern for what it most likely is. The same deceiver Paul warned us about, wearing the costume of the space age. The same lying voice that whispered to Eve in Eden ("you will be like God, knowing good and evil"), now whispering through a hologram on a spacecraft ("you will be like the cosmic ones, knowing your true divinity"). The clothing has changed. The voice has not.
We do not need to be afraid of these accounts. We need to be discerning about them. The Christ who silences abductions with His name is the same Christ who calms our hearts when we hear strange testimonies. We test the spirits because we belong to Him, not because we are afraid of them.15 In Chapter 28, we will turn to the most subtle counterfeit of all: not aliens, not channeled spirits, but New Age teachings dressed in Christian clothing. The pattern of deception, we will see, runs deeper than spaceships.
Bates, Gary. Alien Intrusion: UFOs and the Evolution Connection. Updated edition. Powder Springs, GA: Creation Book Publishers, 2010.
Cooper, John W. Body, Soul, and Life Everlasting: Biblical Anthropology and the Monism-Dualism Debate. Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans, 2000.
Farris, Joshua R. An Introduction to Theological Anthropology: Humans, Both Creaturely and Divine. Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Academic, 2020.
Long, Jeffrey. God and the Afterlife: The Groundbreaking New Evidence for God and Near-Death Experience. New York: HarperOne, 2016.
Miller, J. Steve. Is Christianity Compatible with Deathbed and Near-Death Experiences? The Surprising Presence of Jesus, Scarcity of Anti-Christian Elements, and Compatibility with Historic Christian Teachings. Acworth, GA: Wisdom Creek Press, 2023.
Sabom, Michael. Light and Death: One Doctor's Fascinating Account of Near-Death Experiences. Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 1998.
Tabatt, Shaun. The NDE Conspiracy. Shippensburg, PA: Destiny Image, 2025.
Wilkinson, Michael A. Crowned with Glory and Honor: A Chalcedonian Anthropology. Eugene, OR: Wipf & Stock, 2022.